A Separate School System for Williamsburg?
Joe,
has there been any more talk amongst your planning commission folks and/or neighbors regarding the separation of the city-county schools? It is my view that this is the time to make the break. In addition to my concerns as a parent and taxpayer, I am none too pleased seeing children bused long distances to remote county schools. Many of these folks don’t have cars and these distances have serious repercussions on their daily lives.
What are your thoughts on the school issue?
David-
This is a very big issue and one that I do not have a complete answer to. Here are some brief thoughts.
1. I think the area needs more regional cooperation, not less. The WJC schools have been a step in that direction for many years and I worry that to dissolve the partnership would set us back quite a ways. For this reason I am in against separation.
2. The infrastructure to set-up and run a school system must be enormous! We would have to think very carefully about the costs of such a move. For this reason I am cautious about separation.
3. A primary objective for me is to make the City of Williamsburg a great place to live, and show other people why it is so. Having our own school system could be yet another in a very long list of things the City has going for it. I can easily see people choosing to move into the City because of our small, personalized schools that offer something virtually unheard of in today’s world. This could have a tremendous positive influence for our citizens. For this reason I am in support of separation.
That’s all I have for now. Please continue to stir up the pot. It is an issue that needs discussion. - Joe
Email this discussion to a friend
Friday, May 19, 2006 | Posted by Joe Hertzler
(2) Comments | Filed under General Discussions
I am not sure that separation would hurt regional cooperation, depending on how it is done. If we petulantly state “its our ball and we are going home!” then problems will arise. If, for example, we go to a slow dissolve where we let current high school students phase out and graduate, all the while allowing the county to use the city’s surplus middle school classroom space until such time that the new school already slated for construction can be built, that would greatly reduce the shock to the county system.
Clearly the two localities are traveling different paths. The county population will continue to grow at the current rate or greater for the next 20 years even if a complete moratorium on rezoning went into effect today. The city population increase is modest, with the number of school aged children fairly flat. I applied for a job in Wake County, NC a few years back. One of the primary reasons I turned it down was that they too are in boom mode and the school districts are shuffled nearly every year. I talked to parents in the system and they said the teachers were great and they liked the schools overall, but it was very stressful on the kids to be shifted around every year. They also complained about overcrowding of schools. That is what we can look forward to with JCC. This redistricting will occur on a biannual basis from here on out. There are already two more on the books.
We pay $10m to educate 789 students - $12,600 each! Plus providing three school facilities. That more that double Providence Classical School’s $6k tuition. The shift to an all city school system will bump up noticeably the % of the “free lunch” students we hear so much about, but the significantly smaller classroom sizes should compensate for it.
We have a great model nearby to look at in the Town of West Point Public Schools. That is a simple working class town, but because they too have a stable school age population, a solid tax base and a commitment to excellence, their schools are among the best in the state. Academically, they are up their with the better Fairfax County Schools.
Cooperation occurs where it is mutually beneficial. I see the benefit of shared schools for JCC, but the benefit for Williamsburg is a bit fuzzy to me. It will be a heck of a lot easier to just sign on the dotted line and renew the contract, but I am sure that it is not the best thing for the city’s students.
Posted by | Thursday, May 25, 5:54 pm